This review was done to test the performance of 3 different cement boards (backer board) for : The Wedi Backerboard, Hardibacker® and Wonderboard® FIBEROCK® Aqua-Tough™ Interior Panels are high-performance panels that resist moisture, mould and fire as well as dents and penetration. When properly specified, installed, and covered with tile according to industry standards, a Denshield wall installation is capable of providing the same level of service as a properly installed mortar bed installation. (Breathing this dust is bad, so cut outdoors and use a dust mask.) Discussion in 'Ceramic and Stone Q&A' started by copenrc, Oct 14, 2010. Backsplashes and some tile wainscot can be set on regular drywall (or fiberglass versions of drywall). This product weighs 22.6 pounds per sheet. ). Compare db0b0a8980381414f0572b6d14. Fiberock seems much stiffer to me, although I know that ultimately means not much of anything. Fiberock® Aqua-Tough™ Interior Panels are engineered to provide increased resistance to impact, moisture, mold, abrasion and indentation for interior walls … Re: Denshield vs. Durock? I'm able to get Rockon screws to set in on the Wonderboard by driving them, backing them … It seems that building officials now agree. HardieBoard is in between at 2.6 pounds sq ft or 39 pounds for a 3 x 5 foot sheet. Label- Durock Next Gen has a blue Next Gen logo on the label, traditional Durock does not Weight - Durock Next Gen is 25% lighter than traditional Durock. The main consideration for backer choice is the location of the tile. x 3 ft. x 5 ft. Underlayment is a water-resistant underlayment that delivers support for hardwood, ceramic tile, carpeting and more, in homes or light commercial buildings. speak for all individuals who endeavor to compare different products like those listed above, nor does it intend to sway opinion from one product to another. The Fiberock is supposed to be easier to work with. you know your not going to have problems, although both the fiberock and hardi reps will boast about the reasons why you should use there products in a shower too, i have heard reports of issues with both. Title: Tile Industry Experts Choose USG Fiberock® Products for New Southern Coastal Home Project Profile (English) - F313 Created Date: The tile layout is pretty intricate, with … USG Fiberock Tile Backerboard and Underlayment should not be used in exterior applications. 1DensShield can only be used in residential steam room applications with a maximum shower size of 48 sq. Seller Description. Re: Durock vs Wonderboard I had to tile all the tile floors in this house and a few others, and I like the Durock but was forced to use Wonderboard a few times due to availability. In my area the cost of a 3 x 5 foot ½ inch thick sheet of any of these products runs about $11. So brittle. The exact fire rating of Durock is dependent on the other materials used during construction, but a panel 1/4 or 1/2 inch thick typically provides an additional hour of fire protection. ft. 1/2” BackerBoard comparison chart durock ® Board and durock ® next Gen WonderBoard ®permaBase densshield ® Board Fiberock ® aqua-tough™ interior panel & Backerboard Greenboard PRODUCT COMPOSITION Portland cement, ground sand Call us at (866) 441-6648, Get quotes from qualified local contractors, The Pros and Cons of Installing Saltillo Tile, © Copyright 2020 Networx Systems, Inc. All Rights Reserved. This lightweight and versatile system is extremely durable and allows faster construction speeds for residential and commercial buildings. It’s a sort of gray/beige colored board and is available at any hardware box store. Fiberock is another popular product in this category. HardieBoard’s “grain” is very fine and does not release the fine gravel-like particles the other aggregate type products do. That equates to 36 pounds for the lighter weight Durock and 45 pounds for the WonderBoard. Fiberock Brand 1/4 in. Very lightweight, cuts all the way thru with one pass of a razor knife. The other main type is what I call the “Hardie” type. I'm using EZ board on some showers I'm working on now. It makes more dust this way, but it is fast and leaves a very clean edge. Re: ditra vs cement board Our tile installed switched from Durock to Ditra a few years back - we have been very happy. HardieBacker is a non-aggregate based product from James Hardie, the same company that makes HardiePlank siding. Both of these boards are a cement and aggregate core with a fiberglass mesh “skin.” Durock from USG is a slightly lighter weight version of comparable construction methods. The board is strong and accepts thin-sets and Ardex 8+9 well. FIBEROCK Aqua-Tough tile backer board is a unique fiber-reinforced gypsum product that represents a new era in substrate performance for wet or dry areas as recogniz ... View Details Durock Cement Board with EdgeGuard. Water and gypsum-based backers = mush in my book. That wouldn't be your bonding issue would it? There are several acceptable applications of cement board in the shower. Sometimes, a bad installation process will also change the view of a contractor who may change his mind about a product Sizes and Packaging: USG Durock™ Interior Tape: Rolls, 2" x 50' and 2" x 250'. If you are used to handling Durock, Durock Next Gen will feel much lighter--about 13 lbs for a 3' x 5' sheet. Wonderboard lite is a cement board but with a lower carbon foot print. We recently had to remove a bath floor that was installed on Ditra - I thought it would just require a flat shovel or scrapper to get under the ditra and separate it form the sub floor. We must all put a value on our time. Backer Board & Cement Board. Weights range from 2.4 pounds / sq ft to 3.0 pounds / sq ft for the ½” thick stock. To give you an idea of how tough that is, fiberglass-skinned “drywall” like DensShield is only 450-600 psi compressive. Hope this helps. It has an integral water-resistant composition that offers durability, superior performance, exceptional bond, and is not susceptible warping. Permabase is National Gypsum’s product and it is very much like WonderBoard from Custom Building Products. Gypsum Company: DUROCK, FIBEROCK, USG, USG in stylized letters. You can score this for cuts, but I use a thin diamond dry cutting blade in my grinder. You’ve probably heard of Hardiebacker tile backer board. In the past, I have always used 3/8" Durock on the floors under the tile. That old green board was still paper-based and mold loves to eat paper. Tile can be set just about anywhere, most commonly on floors and walls. Cost, strength, and weight will vary from product to product. I used 1/4" Fiberock on floors for a while, but I wasn't a big fan of it. Looking for a Pro? What was more surprising was that cement-based backer boards were available when this home was built and this green board use reflects a cost-cutting measure that is usually a mistake. Technically called a cementitious backer unit (CBU), well-known brand names of tile backer include Durock, Denshield, HardieBacker, and WonderBoard. These numbers can mean a lot when you need to carry a dozen sheets up three flights of stairs (like a project I did a few months ago). A tile setter buddy stopped by saw the EZ board, and said,"You put the writing to the outside?" USG offers architects, construction project managers, and builders tile backer boards and cement board panels that are ideal for any application. Unlike traditional water-resistant gypsum board, Fiberock® Brand Tile Backerboard is made of a uniquely uniform composition, which creates a strong, mold-resistant product that holds tough when wet. I set my first tiles on it today. HardieBacker – My favorite backer board. Ten bucks per 3x5 sheet. Two (2) pallets sustained damage due to being rubbed by their restraints during shipment. Wonder, permabase and durock cut the mesh, snap, cut the other side, for shower controls, cut the mesh on both sides and tap out with a hammer. Usually, Durock vs. HardieBacker is a result of contractor preference. Looking for opinions on Fiberock vs. Cement board, to be installed in a shower/tub surround. I'd take the Fiberock back and have them order Hardiboard for you - or do a bit more searching to source the proper material. It will work, I have done this type of install many times. Durock NextGen Cement Board Mold resistant drywall is exactly as it states. An added bonus to cement board use is its resistance to mold growth. Ease of installation and time saved. The “Hardie” type is more than double in both areas: 1700 psi flexural and 6500 psi compressive. Durock from USG is a slightly lighter weight version of comparable construction methods. For more information about Continental products, please visit The WonderBoard there, in my 200 sq foot cabin, gave me about half of my estimated 1200 to 1400 pound thermal mass floor. You can compare the MSDS (material data safety sheets) for Fiberock and regular moisture resistant drywall (i.e.greenboard) and you'll find that the … These panels have no paper face to delaminate, tear or scratch, ensuring the product maintains its integrity. Level the joints. Share this post. - … Durock is manufactured in sheets with a thickness of anywhere from 1/4 to 5/8 inch, a width of 32, 36 or 38 inches and a length between 4 and 10 feet. The ¼” thick versions are usually about a dollar cheaper. If a contractor likes a certain kind of product, they are more likely to use it more often, and that results in product bias. Fiberock Vs Durock In a shower application, i still revert back to good ol wonderboard or durock. In this particular case the shower tile was still intact, which is a rarity considering the tile was set on green board. Custom Building Products chiefly sells WonderBoard Lite, identified by the green band across it. Where the biggest differences lie, however, are in the strength department. It is made just like regular drywall except that is had more fiberglass in it and the paper has less organic product in it. All are made of 100-percent inorganic materials that will not rot, shrink, delaminate, or decompose when exposed to moisture. The Fiberock might work for a bathroom, but it ain't going to cut it for an outdoor kitchen. Back in the old days, green board was widely used as a tile substrate. USG Durock™ Exterior Tape over all joints and embed in basecoat. If waterproofing is desired, use USG Durock™ Brand Waterproofing Membrane. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register. It’s mold resistant. People would be making a big mistake to use it now. Talk about a solid floor. 1/4 in. Link to post Share on other sites. I use either Permabase or Durock with a liquid membrane, or sheetrock with Kerdi. ** USG FibeRock VHI does not meet Level 1 abrasion resistance. It's kind of nasty stuff but it works great. I have used all of these products over the years, and I chose WonderBoard for my cabin's floor primarily for its highest mass; in that project I was looking for thermal mass in a passive solar design. I guess it's about as good as Hardibacker. Tile Backers DUROCK® WonderBoard® Util-A-Crete® PermaBase® Daltile ® ProTEC™ FIBEROCK ® Dens Shield HARDIBACKER KERDI- BOARD WEDI 1/2" 3 x 51/2" 3 x 5 DuraBacker Manufacturer USG Custom Building Products Fin-Pan National Gypsum National Gypsum Fin-Pan USG Georgia Pacific JamesHardieSchluter® GmbH Composition Cement/Fiberglass composite panel 1/2" on the walls. (It was banned from use for “wet areas” with the 2006 IRC building code.) The difference in the cost of cement board - that is 100% water resistant - vs dry wall is so insignificant that there is absolutely no reason to risk - even a small failure of the membrane. See USG Durock™ Brand Waterproofing Membrane submittal This truck load of Fiberock and Durock Underlayment has been abandoned in a Louisiana warehouse.The seller would like to recover funds and inventory space. As a tile contractor, I have even installed some on ceilings. But you may also find some of the other versions of WonderBoard still being sold. There are approximately 25 pallets. Looking for opinions on Fiberock vs. Cement board, to be installed in a shower/tub surround. Durock, made by USG, is a similar competing backer board that has a smooth consistency. Durock in my opinion hands down is the cheapest backer board on the market. The issue that needs to be addressed is what tiles and materials should be used for a particular application. 2. DUROCK® Cement Board is a superior alternative to traditional construction methods such as brick walls or AAC blocks. The other main type is what I call the “Hardie” type. In a shower application, I still revert back to good ol wonderboard or durock. Do not overlap pieces of the tape. Thinset on the subfloor, Durock laid on top and screwed down every 6" with the approved screws and never had an issue. Mold Resistant Drywall vs. Durock. Custom Building Products has their version of this, called Rhino board, but they limit it to ¼” thick and recommend it for floors and countertop installations. Public Forums for the PRO, DIYer & Consumer, (You must log in or sign up to reply here. The Fiberock is supposed to be easier to work with but will it or does it work as well as cement board. Hardi and Fiberock are harder to cut without shears or a grinder or carbide blade in a jig saw for your shower controls and the dust is very harmful. Hardiebacker's composition is 90% cement and sand- making it a cement backerboard- while Fiberock is made from 80% gypsum. x 3 ft. x 5 ft. Cement Board with EdgeGuard USG Durock Brand Cement Board with EdgeGuard USG Durock Brand Cement Board with EdgeGuard offers architects, builders and tile contractors a strong, water-durable tile base for tub and shower areas. I think the main reason it had survived was that it was relatively new, as this house was only built in 1996. Earlier this month, I started with a shower tile renovation for one of my Denver tile contracting clients. USG Durock™ Interior and Exterior Tapes are made from alkali-resistant glass-iber mesh. Use FIBEROCK® Aqua-Tough™ Interior Panels on walls, ceilings and exterior dry soffit applications where you need a smooth surface for … So thirsty and worst of all littered with bond breakers. The aggregate-based products are lower in both flexural strength at about 750 to 900 (psi) and in compressive strength at about 2200 to 2500 (psi). I use Kerdi on everything except niches and windows, there I use the 9235 to avoid the " Kerdi buildup". The primary reason is the ease of cutting and lack of crumbly aggregate. Reasons Why: #1). The right backer board for wet or dry areas. Who knows - a faucet stem or a joint could leak slightly in the wall - once that drywall is wet - it's done. My question is this: advantages or disadvantages of Durock vs. DenShield tile backer in a large custom shower- 6′-0 x 6′-0 with two rain hoods in the ceiling and 10 body sprays, two mixing valves, and one hand held nozzle. Do not use in areas subject to prolonged exposure to standing water; for instance, gang showers, saunas and hottub decks. Also an ideal underlayment for tile on floors and countertops in new construction and remodeling. Hardibacker is the best known fiber cement board Fiber cement board. The lack of aggregate in the “Hardie” types reduces the chance of gouging a new acrylic or shinny new enameled tub. USG Durock™ Exterior Tape: Rolls, 4" x 150'. For normal shower installs, I prefer the HardieBoard hands down. HardieBacker is a non-aggregate based product from James Hardie, the same company that  makes HardiePlank siding. Fiber cement board and cement board are closely related.
2020 fiberock vs durock